This website uses cookies to help us give you the best experience when you visit our website. By continuing to use this website, you consent to our use of these cookies. For full details visit https://www.iainabernethy.co.uk/legal-information
I agree it’s a little odd for Sam Harris to write such an article … but it’s a pretty good article! The following quotes stood out for me:
“It may seem onerous to prepare yourself and your family to respond to violence, but not doing so is also a form of preparation. Failing to prepare is, generally speaking, preparing very well to do the wrong thing.” – Sam Harris
“Herein lies a crucial distinction between traditional martial arts and realistic self-defense: Most martial artists train for a “fight.” Opponents assume ready stances, just out of each other’s range, and then practice various techniques or spar (engage in controlled fighting). This does not simulate real violence.” – Sam Harris
Some good material for sure but mostly it felt like a rehash for me with some indications of naivety of behalf of the author.
His ‘crucial distinction between traditional martial arts and realistic self-defence’ is tired at best and in no way reveals any understanding of how traditional arts work.
I agree with most of the article but was not left feeling that the author had any genuine understanding of the subject under review.
I agree it’s a little odd for Sam Harris to write such an article … but it’s a pretty good article! The following quotes stood out for me:
“It may seem onerous to prepare yourself and your family to respond to violence, but not doing so is also a form of preparation. Failing to prepare is, generally speaking, preparing very well to do the wrong thing.” – Sam Harris
“Herein lies a crucial distinction between traditional martial arts and realistic self-defense: Most martial artists train for a “fight.” Opponents assume ready stances, just out of each other’s range, and then practice various techniques or spar (engage in controlled fighting). This does not simulate real violence.” – Sam Harris
Thanks for making us aware of this GNARL!
All the best,
Iain
Good article !
Now linked off our website !
Fantastic. Sam Harris is one of my favourite authors and thinkers. This just adds to that. :)
Some good material for sure but mostly it felt like a rehash for me with some indications of naivety of behalf of the author.
His ‘crucial distinction between traditional martial arts and realistic self-defence’ is tired at best and in no way reveals any understanding of how traditional arts work.
I agree with most of the article but was not left feeling that the author had any genuine understanding of the subject under review.